Tell if Judd dies or not.
Did Shiloh die?
In my four Shiloh books, Judd has a serious accident, but he doesn’t die. Neither does Shiloh. In real life, however, the little dog I found in West Virginia that inspired the Shiloh books, was adopted by a loving couple, friends of ours in Shiloh, W. V., and lived a happy life until she (it was a female dog) died in 2000 and is buried there, with a tombstone over the grave, on their property.