why is Judd so mean?
Did you ever cry during the book when you wrote it? My favorite part was when at the end of chapter 8 when Ma sees Marty with Shiloh and then the chapter ends. I absolutely love the suspense. Also why is Judd so mean, was he the person who was supposed to be mean to Shiloh?
Yes, Judd was the one who was mean to Shiloh, and he was the one who was himself mistreated when he was a boy.