Movie or book?

Comment:

I loved your book. We read Shiloh in my class and watched the movie. It was great. My aunt and her family had a dog named Shiloh and looked like Shiloh in the book. Which ending did you like better? The movie or the book.What made you come up with the backers dog. Hope you can respond to me. Thank you.

Phyllis replied:

I liked my ending best for the book, but movies like to have a lot of action, so the producer’s ending worked well for the movie.