Shiloh

My question about Shiloh/Clover is that did she have any puppies? My favorite part of the book is when Marty gets to keep Shiloh. I likes that part because it felt good to know that Shiloh is in good hands and after multiple times Marty finally gets to keep him. The lesson for the book that i learned is to not judge someone on how they are. Like people that Judd was really mean but in the end he was actually starting to show that he can be nice. I really likes the ending because 1 Marty got to keep Shiloh and 2 because it showed that Judd can be nice and 3 because everything in the other chapters was resolved at the end.

No, Shiloh did not have puppies.  One of the things I’ve learned from life is that most of the time, people who are mean are really miserable, and they often treat others the way they were treated when they were younger.  I’m so glad you liked the book.