Shiloh movie

Dear Mrs Naylor, sorry i’m doing this again but I forgot to tell you my name. My name is Andrew and I have the same question, Why did Judd give Marty the collar in the book but not in the movie? Why is that? And in the end of the movie, why is Judd still mean but not in the book? That’s all I have to ask, AGAIN. But I hope you respond back to me.

When producers buy the movie rights to a book, they are allowed to make changes  in the story which they think will make a more interesting film.  Producers usually add more action to a movie than was in the story–it’s up to them.   Judd is much meaner in the movie, and that helps insure that when the second movie comes out about the second book, the audience will be even more eager to see what happens next.