Shiloh was great!!! Thanks for such a wonderful book!

why did Judd become a good guy? I thought he was bad. My favorite part of the book was probably the part where Shiloh met Marty for the first time because I thought it was cute. I did not like the ending because I think that if Marty’s parents were eavesdropping on Judd when he said “Boy, you are sure doing a whole lot of work for nothing” then heard that part about the witness, Judd never turned into a good guy, but Marty’s parents got Shiloh back.

It was Marty who got Shiloh back.  As mean and miserable as Judd was, I think he was impressed by this young boy who was willing to stick to his side of the bargain, no matter what.  There are four books in the Shiloh quartet and it’s like one long story:  Shiloh, Shiloh Season, Saving Shiloh and A Shiloh Christmas.  Once you read all four, you’ll find out what happens to Judd Travers and Marty and Shiloh in the end.