The book and movie were great

Our class finished the book,Shiloh and watched the movie and I thought they were great. I really liked the part where Marty discovered Shiloh it was really great. It was so surprising when at the end of the movie Judd took Shiloh away but out of nowhere Marty got to keep Shiloh. I have a question, if the german shepherd did not attack Shiloh what would have happened.

If the German shepherd had not attacked, I’m sure that Marty’s parents would have found out about Shiloh some other way.  A dog doesn’t stay hidden for long.  Whether the father would have been so willing to keep Shiloh for awhile, if he had not been injured, no telling….